Disc one
“Wonderful! Wonderful!” (Sherman Edwards, Ben Raleigh) – 2:50
“When Sunny Gets Blue” performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Marvin Fisher, Jack Segal) – 2:41
above two recorded on 9/20/56 and released on 11/5/56
“It’s Not for Me to Say” from Lizzie (1957); performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Robert Allen, Al Stillman) – 3:05
“Warm and Tender” from Lizzie (1957); performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Burt Bacharach, Hal David) – 2:23
above two rec. 9/20/56, rel. 2/25/57
“Chances Are” performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Robert Allen, Al Stillman) – 3:03
“The Twelfth of Never” performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:28
above two rec. 6/16/57, rel. 8/12/57
“Wild Is the Wind” from Wild Is the Wind (1957) (Dimitri Tiomkin, Ned Washington) – 2:26
rec. 10/1/57, rel. 11/11/57
“No Love (But Your Love)” performed with Ray Conniff & His Orchestra (Billy Myles) – 2:34
rec. 6/16/57, rel. 11/11/57
“When I Am with You” (Al Stillman, Ben Weisman) – 3:15
“Come to Me” from the Kraft Television Theatre episode “Come to Me” (1957) (Robert Allen, Peter Lind Hayes) – 3:21
above two rec. 10/31/57, rel. 12/30/57
“All the Time” (Ray Evans, Jay Livingston) – 2:44
rec. 1/7/58, rel. 3/17/58
“Teacher, Teacher” (Robert Allen, Al Stillman) – 2:38
rec. 10/31/57, rel. 3/17/58
“A Certain Smile” from A Certain Smile (1958) (Sammy Fain, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:47
rec. 5/12/58, rel. 6/2/58
“Let It Rain” (Al Frisch, Sid Wayne) – 2:38
rec. 1/7/58, rel. 6/2/58
“Call Me” (Belford Hendricks, Clyde Otis) – 2:46
“Stairway to the Sea (Scalinatella)” (Albert Beach, Giuseppe Cioffi ) – 2:34
above two rec. 5/12/58, rel. 9/8/58
“You Are Beautiful” from Flower Drum Song (1958) (Oscar Hammerstein II, Richard Rodgers) – 3:10
rec. 11/10/58, rel. 12/1/58
“Let’s Love” (Richard Ferraris, Norman Kaye) – 2:41
rec. 9/26/58, rel. 12/1/58
“Someone” (William J. Tennyson, Jr.) – 2:58
rec. 9/26/58, rel. 3/9/59
“Very Much in Love” (Ray Ellis, Al Stillman) – 2:46
rec. 11/10/58, rel. 3/9/59
“I Look at You” (Johnny Mathis, Jessie Mae Robinson) – 2:59
CD bonus track from Johnny’s Greatest Hits; rec. 1/7/58, rel. 3/17/58
“The Flame of Love” (Lee Pockriss, Paul Vance) – 2:51
CD bonus track from More Johnny’s Greatest Hits; rec. 4/29/59, rel. 6/22/59
Personnel
Mitch Miller – producer (tracks 1–21)
Al Ham – producer[A] (tracks 1–3, 7, 13;[4][5] 5, 6, 8, 12;[4] 18, 19, 22)
Ray Conniff – conductor (tracks 1–6, 8); chorus conductor (track 1)
Ray Ellis – conductor (tracks 7, 9–21)
Glenn Osser – conductor (track 22)
A While this compilation only credits Ham as producer for tracks 18, 19, and 22 on this disc, the other compilations listed in the Notes section credit him as such on the tracks indicated. Neither the original singles nor the compilations released before these provided this information.

Disc two
“Small World” from Gypsy (1959) (Stephen Sondheim, Jule Styne) – 3:18
rec. 4/29/59, rel. 5/25/59
“You Are Everything to Me” (Percy Faith, Carl Sigman) – 2:56
rec. 11/10/58, rel. 5/25/59
“The Story of Our Love” (Michael Colicchio, Anthony Piano) – 2:24
rec. 4/29/59, rel. 9/14/59
“The Best of Everything” from The Best of Everything (1959) (Sammy Cahn, Alfred Newman) – 2:45
rec. 9/8/59, rel. 9/28/59
“Cherie” (Michael Coldin, T. Prescott) – 2:49
rec. 5/1/59, rel. 9/28/59
“Starbright” (Lee Pockriss, Paul Vance) – 2:48
rec. 4/29/59, rel. 2/15/60
“All Is Well” (Jerry Leiber, Mike Stoller) – 2:31
rec. 5/1/59, rel. 2/15/60
“Hey Love” (Lee Pockriss, Paul Vance) – 2:28
rec. 5/1/59, rel. 5/9/60
“My Love for You” (Abner Silver, Sid Wayne) – 3:07
“Oh That Feeling” (Jack Segal, Paul Vance) – 2:36
above two rec. 5/31/60, rel. 7/25/60
“How to Handle a Woman” from Camelot (1960); performed with Percy Faith & His Orchestra (Alan Jay Lerner, Frederick Loewe) – 3:02
rec. 10/27/60, rel. 11/7/60
“While You’re Young” (Barbara Hayden, Tony Romano) – 2:54
rec. 5/1/59, rel. 11/7/60
“You Set My Heart to Music” from Thirteen Daughters (1961) (Eaton Magoon, Jr.) – 2:46
rec. 3/4/61, rel. 3/20/61
“Jenny” (Jack Segal, Paul Vance) – 2:58
rec. 2/8/61, rel. 3/20/61
“Should I Wait (Or Should I Run to Her)” (Leon Carr, Paul Vance) – 2:48
rec. 2/8/61, rel. 4/24/61
“Laurie, My Love” (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:25
rec. 3/4/61, rel. 6/16/61
“Wasn’t the Summer Short?” (Ruth Lyons) – 2:53
rec. 2/8/61, rel. 9/8/61
“There You Are” (Clyde Otis, Chris Towns) – 2:48
rec. 9/26/58, rel. 9/8/61
“My Kind of Christmas” performed with Percy Faith & His Orchestra (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 3:02
“Christmas Eve” performed with Percy Faith & His Orchestra (Allyn Ferguson, Sidney Shaw) – 2:56
above two rec. 9/11/61, rel. 11/17/61
“Sweet Thursday” (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:30
“One Look” (Arthur Hamilton) – 2:52
above two rec. 10/9/61, rel. 12/29/61
“Marianna” from The Counterfeit Traitor (1962) (Alfred Newman, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:50
rec. 3/29/62, rel. 4/27/62
“Unaccustomed As I Am” (Ray Ellis, Al Stillman) – 2:55
rec. 3/4/61, rel. 4/27/62
“That’s the Way It Is” (Leon Carr, Paul Vance) – 2:49
rec. 3/29/62, rel. 7/27/62
Personnel
Al Ham – producer (tracks 1–8, 18)
Mitch Miller – producer (tracks 9–12, 18)
Frank DeVol – producer (tracks 13, 16, 24)
Irving Townsend – producer (tracks 14, 15, 17, 19–23, 25)
Glenn Osser – conductor (tracks 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10)
Ray Ellis – conductor (tracks 2, 13–18, 24)
Ralph Burns – conductor (tracks 5, 8, 12)
Percy Faith – conductor (tracks 11, 19, 20)
Pete King – conductor (tracks 23, 25)
no conductor is indicated for tracks 21 & 22

Disc three
“I’ll Never Be Lonely Again” (Sherman Edwards, Aaron Schroeder) – 3:08
rec. 5/23/60, rel. 7/27/62
“Gina” (Leon Carr, Paul Vance) – 2:46
rec. 8/9/62, rel. 9/7/62
“I Love Her That’s Why” (Jack Segal, Paul Vance) – 2:27
rec. 10/9/61, rel. 9/7/62
“What Will Mary Say” (Eddie Snyder, Paul Vance) – 3:09
rec. 8/9/62, rel. 1/4/63
“Quiet Girl” (Marvin Fisher, Jack Segal) – 2:56
rec. 10/9/61, rel. 1/4/63
“Every Step of the Way” (Robert Allen, Al Stillman) – 3:21
rec. 5/31/60, rel. 5/7/63
“Sooner or Later” (Thomas Garlock, Alan Jeffreys) – 3:15
rec. 8/9/62, rel. 7/30/63
“I’ll Search My Heart” (Allyn Ferguson, Ernie Richman, Neil Westen) – 3:02
rec. 8/9/62, rel. 11/5/63
“All the Sad Young Men” (Jerry Livingston, Paul Francis Webster) – 3:02
rec. 3/29/62, rel. 11/5/63
“Don’t Talk to Me” (Milt Gabler, Bert Kaempfert, Herbert Rehbein) – 3:11
rec. 5/15/67, rel. 8/15/67
“Among the First to Know” (Fred Haber) – 2:57
rec. 11/2/67, rel. 11/29/67
“Long Winter Nights” (Gene Allan, Ron Dante, Bob Feldman) – 2:35
rec. 10/20/67, rel. 11/29/67
“Night Dreams” (Bert Kaempfert, Herbert Rehbein, Charles Singleton) – 2:49
rec. 7/5/68, rel. 9/3/68
“Whoever You Are, I Love You” from Promises, Promises (1968) (Burt Bacharach, Hal David) – 3:59
rec. 1/18/69, rel. 4/8/69
“For All We Know” (J. Fred Coots, Sam M. Lewis) – 3:00
rec. 1/6/70, rel. 2/11/70
“Wherefore and Why” (Gordon Lightfoot) – 3:23
rec. 3/25/70, rel. 6/1/70
“The Last Time I Saw Her” (Gordon Lightfoot) – 5:12
rec. 3/25/70, rel. 6/1/70
“Darling Lili” from Darling Lili (1970) (Henry Mancini, Johnny Mercer) – 2:52
rec. 7/10/70, rel. 8/14/70
“Sign of the Dove” (Bradford Craig) – 2:49
“Christmas Is…” (Percy Faith, Spence Maxwell) – 3:06
above two rec. 10/30/70, rel. 11/23/70
“Ten Times Forever More” (Burt Bacharach, Hal David) – 2:36
rec. 1/4/71, rel. 1/21/71
Personnel
Mitch Miller – producer (tracks 1, 6)
Ernie Altschuler – producer (tracks 2, 4, 7, 8)
Irving Townsend – producer (tracks 3, 5, 9)
Robert Mersey – producer, conductor (tracks 10–14)
Jack Gold – producer (tracks 15–21)
Ralph Burns – conductor (track 1)
Don Costa – conductor (tracks 2, 4, 7, 8)
Allyn Ferguson – conductor (tracks 3, 5)
Glenn Osser – conductor (track 6)
Pete King – conductor (track 9)
Ernie Freeman – conductor (tracks 15, 18–20)
Perry Botkin, Jr. – conductor (tracks 16, 17, 21)

Disc four
“I Was There” (Gerry Goffin, Carole King) – 2:26
rec. 1/18/69, rel. 1/21/71
“Evie” (Jimmy Webb) – 3:09
“Think About Things” (Artie Butler, Jerry Fuller) – 2:56
above two rec. 3/19/71, rel. 4/15/71
“If We Only Have Love” (Eric Blau, Jacques Brel, Mort Shuman) – 2:45
rec. 7/8/71, rel. 2/17/72
“This Way Mary” from Mary, Queen of Scots (1971) (Don Black, John Barry) – 3:13
rec. 1/27/72, rel. 2/17/72
“Sometimes” (Felice Mancini, Henry Mancini) – 3:02
rec. 2/11/72, rel. 6/16/72
“I” (Jerry Fuller, D’Arneill Pershing) – 3:05
rec. 9/72, rel. 10/27/72
“Take Good Care of Her” (Arthur Kent, Ed Warren) – 3:01
“Walking Tall” from Walking Tall (1973) (Don Black, Walter Scharf) – 3:34
above two rec. 12/19/72, rel. 1/19/73
“Turn the Lights Down” (Jerry Fuller, Richard Littlefield) – 4:13
rec. 9/22/76, rel. 11/9/76
“Christmas in the City of the Angels” (Suzy Elman; Arnold Goland; Jack Gold) – 2:50
“The Very First Christmas Day” (Clark Gassman, Molly-Ann Leikin) – 3:07
above two rec. 6/5/79, rel. 11/8/79
“The Lord’s Prayer” performed with Gladys Knight & the Pips (Albert Hay Malotte) – 3:26
rec. 5/21/79, rel. 11/18/80
“When a Child Is Born” performed with Gladys Knight & the Pips (Ciro Dammicco, Fred Jay) – 3:52
rec. 4/23/79, rel. 11/18/80
“Nothing Between Us But Love” (Ray Parker, Jr., Candy Parton) – 3:21
Single A-Side also included on The First 25 Years – The Silver Anniversary Album; rec. 11/26/80, rel. 6/19/81
“It Doesn’t Have to Hurt Every Time” (Jim Andron, Candy Parton) – 3:41
CD bonus track from The First 25 Years – The Silver Anniversary Album; rec. 1/18/81, rel. 6/19/81
“There! I’ve Said It Again” (Redd Evans, David Mann) – 2:46
CD bonus track from The First 25 Years – The Silver Anniversary Album; rec. 11/26/80, rel. 6/19/81
“Three Times a Lady” (Lionel Richie) – 4:15
CD bonus track from The First 25 Years – The Silver Anniversary Album; rec. 3/5/80, rel. 6/19/81
“The Way You Look Tonight” from Swing Time (1936) (Dorothy Fields, Jerome Kern) – 3:17
CD bonus track from The First 25 Years – The Silver Anniversary Album; rec. 11/26/80, rel. 6/19/81
Personnel
Robert Mersey – producer, conductor (track 1)
Jerry Fuller – producer (tracks 2, 3, 5–10)
Jack Gold – producer (tracks 4, 11–19)
Al Capps – conductor (tracks 2, 3, 5)
D’Arneill Pershing – conductor (tracks 4, 6–9)
Gene Page – conductor (tracks 10–19)