Track listing

Side one

• “Small World” from Gypsy: A Musical Fable (Jule Styne, Stephen Sondheim) – 3:21
  rec. 4/29/59, rel. 5/25/59;[1] Billboard Hot 100: 20[5]
• “Someone” (William J. Tennyson Jr.) – 2:58
  rec. 9/26/58, rel. 3/9/59;[1] Billboard Hot 100: 35[5]
• “Very Much in Love” (Ray Ellis, Al Stillman) – 2:48
  rec. 11/10/58, rel. 3/9/59;[1] B-side of “Someone”
• “You Are Everything to Me” (Percy Faith, Carl Sigman) – 2:58
  rec. 11/10/58, rel. 5/25/59;[1] Bubbling Under the Hot 100 chart: 109;[5] B-side of “Small World”
• “Let It Rain” (Al Frisch, Sid Wayne) – 2:40
  rec. 1/7/58, rel. 6/2/58;[1] B-side of “A Certain Smile”
• “The Flame of Love” (Lee Pockriss, Jerry Vance) – 2:50
  rec. 4/29/59, rel. 6/22/59;[1] previously unreleased

Side two

• “A Certain Smile” from A Certain Smile (Sammy Fain, Paul Francis Webster) – 2:48
  rec. 5/12/58, rel. 6/2/58;[1] Billboard Most Played by Jockeys: 14[5]
• “Call Me” (Belford Hendricks, Clyde Otis) – 2:48
  rec. 5/12/58, rel. 9/8/58;[1] Billboard Hot 100: 21[5]
• “You Are Beautiful” from Flower Drum Song (Richard Rodgers, Oscar Hammerstein II) – 3:10
  rec. 11/10/58, rel. 12/1/58;[1] Billboard Hot 100: 60;[5] B-side of “Let’s Love”
• “Teacher, Teacher” (Robert Allen, Al Stillman) – 2:41
  rec. 10/31/57, rel. 3/17/58;[1] Billboard Most Played by Jockeys: 21;[5] B-side of “All the Time”
• “Stairway to the Sea (Scalinatella)” (Albert Beach, Giuseppe Cioffi) – 2:36
  rec. 5/12/58, rel. 9/8/58;[1] B-side of “Call Me”
• “Let’s Love” (Richard Ferraris, Norman Kaye) – 2:44
  rec. 9/26/58, rel. 12/1/58;[1] Billboard Hot 100: 44[5]